Reader comments: Lawmakers should listen, not build barriers
13 comments | Read story
It's no coincidence this all ties back to the voucher issue. People who've seen my posts here are probably tired of me saying it - but the legislators cannot let that issue go. They had decided in advance what was best for Utahans regarding vouchers and were angered and humiliated that their constituents did not support them. They forgot that their job is to support what WE want. Legislators want to head off any similar voucher-type defeat by removing our ability to weigh in when they're way off-target.
We need to be vigilant on this issue and vote any legislator out of office who stands in our way by saying, “There’s too much democracy in Utah.”
I agree with you on most everything but not on this issue. The founders didn't want to have a king, but they also didn't want the people to be the legislative body, that's why we have representative government not pure democracy.
We, the people of Utah, have plenty of say in what our legislators do; we can vote them out of office if we don't like them, we can write them letters, visit their homes, and call them. If our failure to act gives lobbyists more power, then that's our fault, not the system's.
I've lived in CA and observed the initiative/referendum process there. It's crazy. Interest groups have even more power there because whoever can pay the most for an ad wins over voters. The founders wanted people who were educated, good, and wise to govern and, yes, listen to the people, but not have the people as a general body vote on issues.
I hope your writing is tongue-in-cheek. The people as a whole are represented only by Senators and Represenatives. Most, if not all, of the organizations you have listed represent people with special interests. Special interest groups are not always a bad thing, in fact, there is a niche in our politics carved out for them (read Federalist No. 10). Just make sure you realize their special interest might not be you -- or in many cases, most other people. As far as Sens. and Reps go, if you want to be represented accurately, write your Congressman or Senator, join a campaign, or get out and vote.
If you don't like what your legislators do, then vote them out of office, even run for office yourself. The CA system is awful. We don't want to go there.
If you don't care what the founders wanted, then you may want to reconsider your opinion. I'm not saying you should believe in everything they did, but to discard everything they say off hand when their opinions were based on the experience and wisdom of generations before them is imprudent. That's one of the major problems of politics today, we assume that we are enlightened and know better than those who came before us. Maybe we do in many cases, but I think it's probably wise to consider very carefully what our predecessors thought and did.
Why the cone of silence and the censorship?
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
- Man still in hospital after Wednesday… 2:13 a.m.
- No gunman found after 3-hour standoff… 2:13 a.m.
- Police engaged in standoff 2:12 a.m.
- '24' is getting good again 1:12 a.m.
- Today on TV 1:12 a.m.
- Obama calls for bold moves 1:11 a.m.
- Utes 2nd in final poll 1:09 a.m.
- Utah should feel like No. 1 1:09 a.m.
- Collie to enter draft 1:07 a.m.
- 80 mph speed limit 1:06 a.m.
-
BYU's '09 football opener is…
186
-
LDS silent on issues
147
-
U. season greatest in our history
146
-
Shurtleff considers BCS probe
135
-
Official 2009 BYU football schedule
111
-
Polygamous leaders arrested
85
-
FLDS mother requests jury for…
84
-
Question for BCS: Why not us?
78
-
Tough Jazz win a streak starter?
76
-
Utah last in per-pupil spending
75
Alabama was #1 in the same polls until Florida beat them. If we stopped then, Alabama…
re: Notevenclose BYU should be ranked no higher than 50 to 60th. What were you…
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Americans must never forget which congressmen/women voted for the failed bailout,…
"Provo" aka "one-trick pony." As this is about the 20th time I have spotted your…
Funny how someone who holds himself out at the only true adjudicator of right and…
I agree, they had no clue. Utah should be No. 5. If the Utes had to play Florida,…
Any date for this study to be published? What are the exact references? Thank…
I think it is stupid, because all the drunk drivers out there will get a little more…
Congratulations, Utah. You had a great season. Let's continue the work in the…

